Perhaps the quality has suffered in the past few years. The set I got for my Chevelle was nice (this was mid 90's), except it is known the window sills, for instance, will be different than the originals, if you're anal about restoration. Otherwise, it was good quality. I actually wanted to get the
Metro seals [that is the name I couldn't remember], but got such a good deal on my kit, I ended up with that. Shame if they aren't as good as they used to be, but these days nothing suprises me with companies.
Problem with repro is it's never the same. Sometimes (rarely) you get lucky and get a superior product, but sadly many times the repro stuff is not as good. My door handles are a good example. damn chinese making classic muscle parts should be a crime, lol.
The saying is true that nothing like the real thing. btw, have you (OP) looked at parted cars and such? Not sure if they can be salvaged, but mayb you can get lucky in finding a better replacement, if nothing else. Rubber and trim pieces are the worst in restoration stuff, as they seem to be the first to go (most owners don't dress their rubbers religiously like they should, if they want to keep it for many years)